spacehorror — Transcription

Rocky
0s
I'm Rocky and this is the show where we pull apart bits of fiction and turn them into role-playing game sessions. We've got a fun one for you this month. A little bit spooky for the spooky season.
Jords
0s
Hi! Welcome to Playtonics! I'm Jords.
16s
Ooh.
Rocky
17s
This month we are talking about space horror. I don't know if this is actually...
Jords
22s
Agoraphobia.
Rocky
23s
Yes, exactly. I don't know if this is actually a genre but we've decided it is and that we want
Jords
30s
yeah I have strong opinions that this this is a genre unto itself yes this is very like in the same way that there's cosmic horror and there's body horror there's definitely space horror
Rocky
40s
Oh, for sure. Space horror is definitely a thing.
43s
I think we can go so far as to say that the genre is just alien and alien clones,
50s
the same way we used to have, like, IBM clones in PC land.
57s
But the face you're making that our listeners in our audio-only podcast cannot see says you disagree with that.
Jords
1m
so controversial
Rocky
1m 4s
So why don't we talk about what space horror actually is?
Jords
1m 8s
all right first of all alien franchise in general is a subset of the superset of space horror right all all of aliens are space horror but not all space horrors are alien
1m 25s
because you got you got space horror that lives by different rules baby but alien is so
1m 30s
totally wound up in its own tropes like it's almost like the genre is aliens and every new movie that comes out in the alien or aliens continuity just is so tightly wound up in those rules that now I don't think they're ever allowed to do anything new anyway space horror more generally I think the first most fundamental pillar of it is that isolation has to be a huge thing like time and distance, matter greatly.
Rocky
2m 1s
Oh yeah, you are alone.
Jords
2m 3s
There's no one coming to save you, but there's always the hope that you might be able to escape the impending doom that's happening.
2m 12s
I think that is the full substrate upon which everything else is
Rocky
2m 17s
That's interesting. I did not have isolation, but as soon as you said it I was like,
2m 20s
yes, that is absolutely one of the core tenets of the genre. It's like, in space no one can hear you scream, not because there's no oxygen or, you know, medium for the sound to travel through or whatever, but because there's no one else out there. No one's coming. Mmm.
Jords
2m 36s
yep it's frontier spookiness right I think you can replicate this a little bit in some of the 1800s ish kind of like isolated house on the the hill kind of a vibe but space takes it one level further because everything is hostile to you so it's like you're just the tiniest blip of life
2m 59s
in either like space proper or on a hostile world where any any collapse in your city systems will cause death
Rocky
3m 3s
that was going to be my opening play was like I think it is the inherent danger of the environment so whether as you said whether you're on a planet whether you are like out in the depths of space like it is an inherently dangerous environment and obviously we're going to add another element of danger to that that I'm sure we'll get to in a second but like it is already a place where just Just going outside in the wrong way will kill you.
3m 33s
You can die of being too cold. You can die of being too hot. You can die of not having enough air. You can die of not having enough gravity. You can die of having too much gravity. All sorts of ways for things to go wrong and basically cause your end.
Jords
3m 50s
And that's part of why it's such a rich space to play in.
3m 54s
You have so many threat vectors.
Rocky
3m 56s
exactly it would be very hard to do have as many ways to die if you were on you know just a regular earth planet it's very hard to do okay well we can do suffocation and we can do freezing to death and we can do like all in the same place which is I think what puts something like alien apart from something like the thing where it's like okay sure if you go outside in antarctic you might freeze to death but like there's very little risk of suffocation like maybe you can drown but there's very little risk of like
4m 27s
being cooked by radiation like space has one of everything there are so many ways to die and i think the the good examples of the genre some of the deaths are just from like
4m 37s
you panicked in space and that is enough
Jords
4m 41s
absolutely there's so many opportunities for the trigger to push you into a worse position where you now have to compromise on like you said radiation safety or like you have to open and vent the air from inside the room to out into space and that causes a blast of a pressure wave like there are so many opportunities that are presented to adventure design and also to the characters like the characters in space horror...
5m 11s
movies or books have to live underneath the weight of all of these constraints.
5m 16s
There's a minimum amount of competence to even be allowed into this environment.
5m 22s
So you've got to be somewhat clever.
5m 24s
You have to have sat through the workplace health and safety PowerPoint deck on all these different things.
5m 30s
And that gives us the opportunity to then fuck with people by manipulating those specific environmental hazards.
Rocky
5m 37s
I think there's another element to this too, which is that it is very easy for you to be short-term okay, but long-term fucked. So like, it's very easy for these things to end in like,
5m 50s
not necessarily immediate death, but the idea of doom. And the one that comes to mind for me on this one is Sunshine, which I think is borderline. Like it's half disaster, it's half the core and half alien right like it's it's really crossing these major up genres but like the the bit in sunshine is like everyone has not immediately died but like this trip is now doomed and it is the bit where it's like the oxygen garden is on fire that's it this is now a one-way trip
Jords
6m 16s
You can have a long tail on your survival horizon, but it's finite.
Rocky
6m 25s
exactly I suppose with that actually it might be a good idea to talk about we've kind of just jumped straight in and that's very cool do we want to maybe give some examples of like the kinds of things that we're talking about
Jords
6m 37s
absolutely look for me the very first the best one the one that I love more than anything else that I saw way too young and re-watched again recently I do this every couple of years is event horizon so good if you've never seen it go watch that movie it has and also laurence fishburne just Just like very competent, great decision makers, still up against a terrible situation. There's no death by stupidity.
Rocky
6m 50s
Oh, yes, I was hoping you would say Event Horizon.
6m 55s
So good.
6m 58s
Sam Neill at his finest.
7m 8s
Yeah, and just such a cool exploration of the idea of, like, the ship literally goes through hell, like...
Jords
7m 19s
I love the fan canon that's like, oh, it went through the warp and is like the start of the Warhammer 40K universe.
Rocky
7m 26s
Yeah, I've heard this one as well. And it like, honestly, it checks out. Yeah, Event Horizon,
7m 31s
absolutely on the list. As I kind of mentioned, Sunshine has some very strong elements of this,
7m 37s
especially once we get into the second act where they find the second ship. And it's like,
7m 44s
what is going on with this guy? Interesting example, because like, the guy is not in any way supernatural or alien. He is just a psycho killer who happens to have looked at the sun a bit too much.
7m 56s
So yeah, some really interesting elements of it in Sunshine.
8m
Also some like really great use of the environment to cause problems in Sunshine.
8m 5s
I think a lot about that scene where they shoot themselves between the two ships just wrapped up in foil and the guy misses the airlock.
8m 16s
And there's a moment where he's like, have I made it yet?
8m 19s
And he just unwraps the foil to have a look to see whether he's made it to the airlock.
8m 24s
And then he realizes that he hasn't made it to the airline.
8m 26s
And then like freezes solid.
8m 27s
It's like, does space actually work like that?
8m 30s
I don't know.
8m 31s
But it's an evocative image to be like, you thought you'd made it and you hadn't.
8m 36s
Just like a beautiful moment of horror.
Jords
8m 36s
Yeah.
8m 38s
The small mistake and you are cooked.
Rocky
8m 41s
You are, well, the opposite of cooked.
Jords
8m 42s
Or frozen.
Rocky
8m 43s
Frozen.
8m 45s
Snap frozen.
8m 46s
Sunshine on the list.
8m 47s
Absolutely.
8m 48s
I think for me, there's some things we can learn from that.
8m 51s
the one I watched in prep for this episode which I don't necessarily really recommend is Life the 2017 who's in it it's like Jake Gyllenhaal and I think Ryan Gosling the basic premise of that one is that they find a life form it's come up from Mars it proceeds to grow from a petri dish and then take over the ship and again some of the things that do the killing are the alien some of the things that do the killing are just the fact that they're on
9m 26s
what is a fairly we'll call it a fairly creatively licensed version of the International Space Station the true horror of life is what they've done to my boy the ISS I think was my exact words yeah so they're on board the ISS and there's just some really good use of like other horrible ways like someone drowns in their space suit like the coolant loop breaks
Jords
9m 34s
Oh man, you're so diplomatic. Before the show started, you were spitting fire about this.
Rocky
9m 56s
in their space suit and the other crew members have to watch as they like slowly drown in their faceplate like nothing to do with the monster but like absolutely horrifying so really interesting use of that like really good use of the environmental hazards I'm trying to find nice things to say about it because it's very silly laughter
Jords
10m 16s
One thing that I do love, do you remember the movie Passengers with Chris Pratt and Jennifer Lawrence? The premise of this movie is it's a generation ship. We'll come back to Ark Ships in a future episode because we love them, but it's a generation ship. It's cruising between Earth and somewhere in the distance. It's going to take a really long time and Chris Pratt accidentally is woken up and then it navigates his loneliness on the ship because he's the only person, the only human who's awake and he eventually unfreezes Jennifer Lawrence and does it in a way that tries to avoid him essentially dooming her to life aboard the ship with him and they have a relationship and somebody recut this as a horror because instead of starting with Chris Pratt going through the emotional turmoil of do I wake somebody up what about this hot babe that I've just found who's asleep and can't consent to me dooming her instead it's portrayed from her perspective.
Rocky
10m 23s
I never saw it.
11m 2s

[laughs]

Jords
11m 16s
And the whole thing is like her trying to navigate, like, is he genuine?
11m 21s
Was this an accident?
11m 22s
Was I pulled into this problem?
Rocky
11m 25s
Hmm.
Jords
11m 25s
And it's so spooky and it's so much better than the original film.
11m 29s
And I think that lens is like a really good takeaway.
11m 34s
Like, if we apply that, it's not just that we're in space and things are hard.
11m 40s
It's that we don't understand everything that's going on.
11m 46s
We may never be able to understand everything that's going on, especially with the, like,
11m 51s
impetus of the threats that are happening to us right now.
11m 54s
And I think one of my favorite tropes in space horror is that, like, it's not even another entity, monster, alien, consciousness thing, but you just bump into somebody else in the depths of space and your magic circle is broken because you can't be sure of their motives.
12m 16s
I think that's real spooky and real tense.
12m 18s
Kind of goes back to what we were saying about the post-apocalypse vibes, where once the environment's really hostile and it takes an awful lot of effort just to stay alive, bumping into somebody else could be the single most dangerous thing that happens.
Rocky
12m 32s
Yeah, absolutely. Anything else on your list before we jump straight back into the tropes?
Jords
12m 37s
Ghosts of Mars by John Carpenter.
Rocky
12m 43s
Oh god, you're a dork.
Jords
12m 46s
There's another one that I watched very recently that was from the 80s, and it was, like, quintessential schlocky space horror.
12m 52s
And I cannot remember the name of it, but it's, like, American astronauts go into space.
12m 57s
They're on the moon.
12m 59s
They find, like, a cybernetic organism that kills people and then wears bits of their body.
13m 6s
And it's got Ash from The Walking Dead, Bruce Campbell, and then they'd go back to, it was a bad movie,
13m 14s
but it does capture a lot of things.
Rocky
13m 15s
I mean I think we run into that a lot right it's like the bad movies and the parody movies as well often like are a better place to look to see the tropes because the thing about tropes is that when they're done well you don't notice them or when you're you're seeing something like novel in the space you're not necessarily seeing the tropes and that's not necessarily a good place to mine for what makes this genre-y if you're seeing someone who is subverting all of the tropes.
Jords
13m 16s
It does capture a lot of the bits of this.
Rocky
13m 47s
So yeah, the bad stuff, the cliche stuff,
13m 49s
also the parody stuff can be a really good place to look.
Jords
13m 53s
now I did also mainline all of the alien and prometheus films earlier in the year and it's
14m
it's just really obvious like the tropes that are present by like the last five movies like the first couple movies are exploring the notion and then by the end it's like they are trapped by the notion they cannot it can't be an alien film unless you have these scenes
Rocky
14m 16s
You're absolutely right. Alien at this point has become formulaic and they've locked themselves into that particular pattern, that particular problem space.
Jords
14m 26s
Right, so there's lots of films that kind of qualify for this, right?
14m 30s
We've got heaps of different options.
14m 33s
We could even, like on the books front, Blindsight by Peter Watts could easily be seen as a space horror.
Rocky
14m 37s
Oh, absolutely, Blindsight and the sequel, Echopraxia, like, yes.
14m 43s
I'm really glad you brought that one up.
14m 44s
I think Blindsight is the reason that you and I are friends.
Jords
14m 48s
I mean, I like to think it's because, you know, we have quality personality traits that intermesh, but like maybe it's blindsight.
Rocky
14m 55s
no that's that's I recommend people blindsight and then if they uh come back to me saying like we have to spend eight hours at a pub talking about this book then i'm like we can be friends uh yeah blindsight absolutely incredible and I think gives a really good structural thing that it might be worth keeping in mind blindsight is is very much they're out exploring a strange object and the book is structured as a series of like incursions into the place.
15m 30s
So it's this like, we have an incursion,
15m 35s
weird stuff happens and then they go back to the ship and they kind of get to deal with it a little bit and then they have a second incursion and these things become more and more, yeah.
Jords
15m 41s
it does feel very traditional dungeon crawl style where it's like we go in we go as far as we can now we have to return and regroup now it's time to go in with a little bit of extra information we've got and try again
Rocky
15m 56s
And I think in that sense, it borrows a little bit from like some of the zone fictiony SCP type stuff where it's like, okay, we are making like expeditions into the weird zone and trying to like go in, learn something or recover something and come out again.
16m 13s
So it borrows from that structure quite heavily.
Jords
16m 18s
It tells us a lot about like the unknowns are so pervading like there's so much dread in the air because you just don't know what you're up against.
16m 29s
And you might see like atmospheric components of it, things to build the tension, but you just never really get the full picture.
Rocky
16m 37s
And every bit of information you get is essentially more questions than answers and opens up more terrifying possibilities than it, you know, closes off.
16m 48s
There is no security to be had in learning new things.
16m 52s
Every new thing you learn, like, opens up awful new possibilities.
Jords
16m 57s
yeah I think blindside is a exceptional example of this where as you learn a little bit more it just shows how ignorant you are like things that never crossed your mind to begin with are things that are brought to the fore and you're like oh that's so much worse than I thought it could be so very good example of it so lots of pre-reading lots of different movies that you can watch for this type of a a vibe let's jump back in to pulling it apart
Rocky
17m 27s
Hmm. Yep.
Jords
17m 27s
so we've got isolation as a key theme we've got an extremely hostile environment
Rocky
17m 33s
I think you've touched on another important one there, which is the unknown, right? Like it's,
17m 39s
it's, I think a cliche at this point to say like, oh, a horror rests on like the unknown.
17m 44s
And you know, that, that classic, like, but the more you show of the monster,
17m 49s
the like the less scary it is. But I think that's definitely true here.
Jords
17m 53s
It's a cliche for a reason.
Rocky
17m 55s
I think a key component of this along with isolation is I would call it like paranoia, right?
18m 2s
It's like, you know,
18m 3s
just enough to know that something is wrong,
18m 7s
but you don't know what it is.
18m 8s
And it really starts to shape like the decision-making processes when you don't have that complete information.
Jords
18m 19s
Yeah, look, that also raises something quite important, I think.
18m 22s
You never have time on your side to fully uncover these things or to do that in a safe manner.
18m 30s
There's always some form of external pressure that pushes you into difficult situations, even against your better judgment.
18m 39s
It can't just be as simple as like, I'll just run away because something is not allowing you to do that.
Rocky
18m 46s
Can I, can I subsume that under something bigger?
Jords
18m 49s
Mmm.
Rocky
18m 50s
Because one of my pillars was claustrophobia, right?
Jords
18m 52s
Mmm.
18m 54s
So I opened this episode with agoraphobia.
Rocky
18m 57s
Yeah.
Jords
18m 59s
Too much space.
19m
Now you're saying there's not enough.
Rocky
19m 2s
Yeah, because the amount of space that you can actually survive in is like very small.
Jords
19m 6s
Yes, tiny box.
Rocky
19m 8s
But like, I think they're the same thing on different, literally in different dimensions,
19m 13s
like you are confined in the amount of literally the amount of room you have to maneuver and you are confined in the amount of time that you have to do it in like every option is constrained you are constrained in space you are constrained in time and it should feel like the walls are pressing in on you and the you know inexorable deadline is is pressing in on you as well like exactly
Jords
19m 42s
The do-nothing approach leads to death.
Rocky
19m 46s
I think I think those are both like different elements of the claustrophobia like there is not enough time there is not enough space there is not enough like safe space and down time like you don't get the chance to decompress you don't have a place to decompress or if you do it is like like it's not tenable it's not viable to stay there right like I think the example of this for me is like in Alien you get these moments of downtime where
20m 16s
goes to talk to the computer and it's like the computer room is sealed and it is safe and it is like well it is literally like lit from every direction there is nowhere for the alien to hide and she goes in there and she gets a moment she gets some answers such as they are and she gets a moment to think but not that long but like it's also extremely obvious that she can't stay in there she can't just hide in the computer room the whole time, like eventually she will have to leave to get a glass of water, right, like to do literally anything else, like she can't stay in there and in life we see the same thing in life, someone like hunkers down into their bunk and they have these like seal off cryopod style sleeping bunks and they like lock the bunk off and the bunk is safe and the bunk is like cozy, there's like a picture of the guy's kids in there and it's like okay the tropes are telling us that he's like safe in this space but also it's literally a coffin like he can't stay in there he has to get out so you have these moments where like it's almost like if you get some time you don't have space and if you have space you don't get time like I love it one of the metaphors i've pulled up on this show for game mastering before is this idea of like we brought it up in the project hail mary thing is this idea of a gear stick and so if you if you're always like switching between these different things that's a good way of making sure you're kind of modulating your tone and maybe that's our like the basis of like a a tonal gear stick for this genre is like if you have time you don't have space and if you have space you don't have time like if you have room to move you know that something's coming for you and if you have time to think you know you can't stay there
Jords
21m 30s
That's a good way of putting it, yeah.
22m 4s
I like that. It's like the only thing you could have time for is to gather some thoughts, but not really progress anything.

Chapter 1

Rocky
22m 13s
yeah there is no way to solve the problem from inside I think the computer's called mother right like there's no way for her to solve the problem from inside mother she's gonna have to go out all right so we've got claustrophobia we've got paranoia we've got isolation I love how like primal and psychological all of these dot points are by the way because like we've got claustrophobia we've got paranoia we've got the goal is escape and survival we've got isolation we know we've got a dangerous environment that will kill you if you are exposed to it in the wrong way. What else we
Jords
22m 46s
I think there's a pacing element that is relevant to all of these stories as well.
22m 52s
You've already touched on this with the like, if you show it too early, it's no longer scary.
22m 56s
But there's a really long lead in where we start with a quite mundane kind of lifestyle where it's like, this is time aboard the ship or we're on the base and it's just super like, here are the processes that we follow. And then the foreshadowing starts and like the sense of dread
23m 16s
begins its build. And we go through a really long period of ramping that up until it eventually becomes unbearable. The big reveal happens. And that's the climax where the players have to do something or the characters have to do something to resolve their situation and try and find that that tiny ray of hope of survival.
Rocky
23m 36s
it's like almost cozy like we're on this little ship the little ship is safe against the scary outside and then something arrives to very much disrupt that
Jords
23m 48s
we have to establish the status quo before you can disrupt on if you just jump straight into disruption there's no baseline and you you don't care about any of the things but if we have the that little bit of time at the start to kind of establish relationships between the people who are going to be embroiled in this mess it gives us a reason to care about any particular individual because otherwise it's just like a slasher film where you're like all right one of these people is going to survive everyone else is going to die I don't really care who
Rocky
24m 15s
I think the other element of that is, like, if you have these characters starting from a safe place, there is a, it gives them room psychologically to indulge in their curiosity a little bit.
24m 28s
I think it's so interesting that so many of these things are, like, as an audience who kind of knows what's going to happen in this genre, we're just like, leave it alone.
24m 40s
But, like, who among us can say that if we were woken up by the computer ahead of schedule and it's,
24m 45s
like, hey, there's something maybe alien down there, like, we're gonna, yeah, it's like, oh, that curiosity, like, we gotta know.
Jords
24m 50s
I'm going to get this whole ship killed. Let's go find out.
Rocky
24m 58s
So, yeah, I think that's a part of it as well.
25m
We start with this, like, quotidian, everyday, cozy, we move into some curiosity, then it becomes obvious that something has gone wrong, and then we escalate to this, like, we see a little bit more of the monster, we see things start to go, like, what on?
25m 15s
What on earth is happening?
25m 17s
Maybe we go down a track of, like, we try to kill it for a while, but I think we eventually end up in this place of, it is just survival.
25m 25s
I think the implicit thing that we haven't talked about here is, like, there is some kind of external force.
25m 33s
We've just been assuming that it's an alien, some kind of monster, but you mentioned earlier, like, it could be another person, like in Sunshine.
25m 41s
I think the Reavers from Firefly are a good example of,
25m 45s
that it's like,
25m 46s
we don't know what is going on here.
25m 50s
We know that they're just people because there's not really aliens in the Firefly verse,
25m 54s
but like you encounter Reavers out in space and it's a very,
25m 57s
a very similar feeling of like,
26m
we don't know what's going to happen.
26m 2s
This ship is a spooky place.
26m 4s
It's full of places that people could jump out of.
26m 7s
Like it's very much disrupted the cozy status quo.
26m 9s
So yeah,
Jords
26m 12s
I even just love the way Reavers are introduced in Firefly, where Mal says something to the effect of, they're men who reached the edge of space and went mad. And it's like, there's something out there. And even though that's resolved later, I love that premise of like, this could happen to us.
Rocky
26m 29s
So yeah, it's easy for us, and we'll probably fall into this trap as we keep talking about it.
26m 33s
It's easy for us to slip into the trap of assuming that there's some kind of monster or some kind of alien.
Jords
26m 38s
Could it just be the environment?
Rocky
26m 40s
I don't think so.
Jords
26m 42s
Why is that?
Rocky
26m 43s
I think if it's just you versus the environment, you're in a disaster movie.
Jords
26m 47s
Like Apollo 13, space horror?
Rocky
26m 51s
No. Disaster movie.
26m 53s
Sunshine without the Psycho. Disaster movie.
Jords
26m 57s
I really tend to agree on this one and like there's a hopeful lens in Apollo and there is still like somewhat a hopeful lens in Sunshine where like they're on a mission to save everyone.
Rocky
27m 12s
what sets it apart from a disaster movie set in space is an antagonist who is actively opposing the players or pursuing their own ends to the player's detriment or the character's detriment
27m 27s
and or is like inscrutable right like we don't actually know what the alien wants except to feed and breed so I think that like inscrutability an inscrutable opponent call it call it that an
Jords
27m 40s
I think that's a real, yeah, something with uncertain motivations that is hostile to you.
27m 47s
Incompatible with you, incompatible with life in this hostile world.
Rocky
27m 52s
Mmm, mmm.
Jords
27m 53s
So yeah, can't just be a difficult environment to persist in.
27m 59s
But there has to be something in there, whether that's like a rogue AI or it's the classic
Rocky
28m 7s
Yeah. Rogue AI is a good one. Yeah. It could be an AI. It could be a computer virus, right? Like there's all sorts of things that it could be, but it has to be somehow malevolent, active.
Jords
28m 18s
Yep, its goals are not compatible with your survival.
Rocky
28m 22s
Yeah. I think that's the important stuff.
Jords
28m 26s
It gives us a lot to work with.
Rocky
28m 29s
There's a lot to work with. So I think we've got a couple of things to talk about here.
28m 35s
we've got some stuff in like how we structure our adventure and then there's absolutely a question of like how we facilitate it at the table I think structurally we want a very confined environment we're prepping a small limited number of spaces I think when we're prepping those we want to think about that like if it's safe you can't do anything from there right like thinking about that computer room situation
29m 7s
yes we probably do need some safe spaces for downtime but like they're not spaces where we can just hide out and achieve anything like and vice versa like when we have options to affordances in the spaces to like actually achieve things those spaces have to be able to be populated with preferably many different unknown dangers so the more solutions to a problem that we put in a space, the more places we have to put bad things to hide slash environmental hazards.
Jords
29m 42s
Absolutely. I think that's a really good way of framing it.
29m 45s
It's like if we put down the things like this is a suit that blocks radiation,
29m 50s
that means you're allowed to introduce radiation later.
29m 53s
So it's like if you have the solutions first, at later points,
29m 56s
you can introduce a twist that requires that solution.
30m
You don't have to start with a problem framing and then work backwards.
30m 3s
You can just be like, what are all the hazards that might happen?
30m 6s
Well, you've got things that can block those.
30m 8s
And now I can deploy them at will.
Rocky
30m 10s
But more importantly, I can make you decide that, for example, we put a flamethrower on the spaceship for whatever reason, thing that would never happen, absolutely never happen on the space station.
30m 20s
But like in life, there is a flamethrower, but like to get the flamethrower, they have to go through a bit where they know the alien is, right?
30m 28s
So like every affordance we put in for a solution, they can't, we can't put those in the safe spaces because going out to get the flamethrower, going out to like, you know, pull the self
30m 40s
destruct switch, all of those things, when I'm mapping them out on our spaceship floor plan, I'm putting them at the like extremes of the ship, right?
30m 52s
Like I'm putting them four rooms away.
30m 54s
It's like, and whether or not that makes sense in universe doesn't matter.
30m 58s
But like the self destruct button is over here, but it also requires you to push a button that's like actually in the cockpit, which is at the other end of the ship, like.
Jords
31m 6s
and I think that's actually like quite easy to justify in world it increases the barrier for someone who's gone space mad for example of you know it requires two people one to press the button and the other to pull the lever for the scuttling charges to trigger or you don't want to have the flamethrower available to somebody at a whim because it'd be too easy to to misuse that the risk of catastrophe is too
Rocky
31m 31s
Yeah. So I think a pattern starts to emerge where we are like, okay, there are things that we need to progress, to survive, things that we can straight up just like tell the players that they exist because they're on the schematic, but to get to them, you are going to have to go through the gauntlet, through the room. And again, I think just like the opposite of the computer room in Alien is the like
32m 1s
which part of the ship it is but it's the part where it's like it is wet for some reason and dripping and there's just like clinking chains everywhere and it's all corners and all shadows and like there are so many places it could be hiding and there are so many false alarms and so many other things that are moving and I think like the cat ends up in there at some point as well and like the cat gives you a jump scare like so they've created this space where like to progress the plot we need to move through this space.
32m 31s
It's not just, like, unsafe.
32m 33s
It's, like, populated entirely with unknowns.
Jords
32m 36s
From a prep perspective, I wouldn't want to have to fill all of those shadows and corners and everything with stuff.
Rocky
32m 43s
You never want to say where the antagonist is, but you want to have so many options for where it could be.
Jords
32m 45s
I just need to know they exist so I can introduce the thing when it's relevant.
32m 51s
It's an affordance for me.
33m 2s
absolutely so like I find it very interesting that you haven't actually framed what the bad entity is we've come at this instead from like isolated environment the base that we're working from here whether it's like a spaceship station like on on a moon whatever it is it's very small it's very claustrophobic and the world is going to kill you so I just have to have a couple of elements that can waylay that and then I get to layer whatever the bad thing is over the top of all of this like my foundation is a location with interesting places and then I can plug in the bad
Rocky
33m 2s
The players should never know where it is.
33m 38s
Mm-hmm. Absolutely.
33m 45s
I don't think it's a coincidence that we both started with these, like, environmental components.
33m 51s
You were like, it's isolation. I was like, it's a dangerous environment.
33m 54s
We were both like, it's claustrophobic and time and space are both constrained.
34m
And you're right, like, the antagonist comes later.
34m 3s
The antagonist is just a horrible forcing afterthought to make you...
34m 8s
...have to confront your isolation and confront your claustrophobia and confront, like, all of this and face the dangerous environment.
34m 17s
Because, like, that's ultimately what it's there for, right?
34m 19s
It's like that the alien is scarier than going out in hard vacuum, right?
34m 25s
Like, whatever it is that we're putting in there with you has to be scary enough to make this already scary environment the better option.
Jords
34m 34s
There is just now a greater of two evils.
Rocky
34m 36s
Exactly. The whole thing is, like, rocks and hard play.
34m 38s
And, like, if you think about the player's decision tree, I'm very much thinking about this as, like, a graph, right?
34m 46s
Like, in the mathematic sense.
34m 47s
But there should be no point where they are not stepping into danger of some kind.
34m 53s
If they step this way, there's this danger.
34m 56s
And if they step this way, there's this danger.
34m 58s
And also probably some unknown dangers that they don't know about.
35m 1s
But as soon as they step out there, that's the new minimum.
35m 3s
and like even to step back that will be the danger will still be climbing
35m 8s
there has to be danger around every corner and the antagonist is just our way of like almost like holding a blow torch to them right like putting a hot poker on their heels like to force them to confront different dangers it's like this is our laser pointer our thing that we get to move around the map and prod them with it's our ultimate kick right but really the whole is space and vacuum and darkness and death and each other like that's that's the other half of the the hard place right like yeah
Jords
35m 50s
the the rock so foundationally we we want a map we want some spatial relationship to these things right whether that map is like hard written down or just like a kind of abstracty like here is a large room that you would have to cross I can introduce challenges to this I don't think it particularly matters it doesn't have to be this is a room that is like six meters by four meters and it has these yeah they're has to be a location description it could be a point crawl it could be just like straight location crawl um I think for my preference I would go full location crawl because I love slapping a map down for the players to navigate like a ship layout or a base layout
Rocky
36m 40s
Yeah, and that is, like, that is functionally the, if we think about tension, which I think we'll get to in a second, but if you think about how we're modulating tension in this section, like, you can't be at, like, vibrato strings, like, for the whole movie, right?
36m 56s
Like, you have to have some downtime.
Jords
36m 57s
It has to be release.
Rocky
37m
Functionally, that downtime in most of these movies is regroup and plan, right?
37m 5s
And I think the map is a perfect tool for that.
37m 10s
All of the options in front of the players and it lets the players do what the characters are doing, which is, like, a lot of the time, like, in the movies, they will sit down in front of a schematic of the ship and point at, like, well, the self-destruct is over here and the escape pod is over here and, like, the characters plan and the players should be able to do the same thing.
37m 28s
And that is, like, in our rollercoaster of tension, release, tension, release, like, those planning moments before we go out into the danger are our...
37m 40s
release. So, as a tool, like, it does so many things for us.
37m 43s
It gives us that, like, ludonarrative resonance where, like, the players and the characters are doing the same thing, which is planning on a map.
37m 50s
It gives us the pacing tool and tone tool of, like, we have a reason to have some downtime, which is to plan the next thing.
38m
And it forces us almost into that structure of out into danger, back to safety, out into danger, back to safety, which is kind of the tonal,
38m 10s
shape of these films where, like, yes, the whole thing is escalating over time, but we do have these moments of downtime.
Jords
38m 17s
Yeah, so, like, plateau-y moments.
Rocky
38m 19s
Yeah, which usually come after a kill.
Jords
38m 23s
Yes, there's usually a spike, and then there's a, like, something has cost us, and now we have to, like, we've paid the price to get our brief moment of respite.
Rocky
38m 25s
Yep.
38m 30s
Something has gone wrong.
38m 33s
Yep.
38m 35s
So we've prepped a space, the other element, the other half of the equation that we talked about is like, oh, if you have space, you don't have time.
38m 43s
And if you have time, you don't have space.
38m 44s
I think for me, the DM, I'm also prepping, perhaps a timeline is too strong a word, but in our classic like platonic style, I'm prepping a series of kicks where like, if the players don't make a decision, we have a way that things will unfold.
Jords
38m 56s
Yes, absolutely.
Rocky
39m 1s
We have some proactive actions that the, again, one of the advantages of having an active antagonist is that they can choose the...
39m 10s
They can decide that it's time to, like, come and hunt you down, actually.
Jords
39m 13s
I think these work really well on multiple fronts like a genuine just straight up spur to action but b we've already established whatever our entity is is inscrutable every time they act it gives a little bit more information to the characters even if they don't know how to make sense of that information it will give them something to speculate on and I think that speculation is fuel for tension.
Rocky
39m 29s
Yeah, like why would it want that?
39m 39s
absolutely and it can even start to sort of you can start to do a very light I think mystery style clue type thing where I would keep it very simple but like you might have something like oh why is it going for the reactor core like why would we see it on the motion tracker going towards the reactor maybe it feeds off heat maybe it feeds off radiation maybe it's like okay well that then becomes a thing that you can use later in kind of your third act to like lure it around and again life did this very badly they just told us that it needed oxygen and then they immediately in the next scene used an oxygen candle to lure it around like that was not set up in advance it was set up like in fact earlier they use an oxygen candle and it harms the thing so it's like it's not even internally consistent but like right like but yes that is kind of the the thing that that lets you do is I wouldn't go too much into, we don't want to know too much about that,
40m 39s
aliens biology, but if we can establish that there's a thing that perhaps it does like,
40m 43s
or perhaps a thing that it doesn't like, as part of those kicks, that can be another tool that we give the players to try and move their way out. And I don't think it needs to be any more complex than is drawn to, is like repelled from, like...
Jords
40m 59s
yep I love that especially when it's a just not quite standard answer to that question so it requires like maybe like two or three instances of being fed this information for you to be able to make that deduction but like you know if it's something as mundane as like likes oxygen doesn't like not oxygen I think players can like con onto that too quickly for my liking I want it to be just like a little bit like likes,
Rocky
41m 21s
Ah, ah, ah, ah, ah.
Jords
41m 29s
unusual feature.
41m 32s
I really want the environment and the entity to like sing to each other in a way.
41m 37s
So even though we can layer one on top of the other,
41m 39s
I want to pick something about the environment that is unique,
41m 43s
that the entity is drawn to, right?
41m 48s
So it's not just like a universal approach.
41m 50s
It's like, oh no,
41m 51s
there's a reason this adventure is happening in this location with this bad guy.
41m 56s
I want to marry the two of them together.
41m 59s
There's one other thing as well.
42m 1s
I kind of, I often actually start with this.
42m 4s
If we've got a location and we know our trope is space horror,
42m 9s
that gives us a lot of latitude on like what I think of as universal problems in this space.
42m 16s
And that's things that we can populate in any given adventure,
42m 20s
which is like airlocks and spacesuits.
42m 22s
There's always an airlock.
42m 25s
There's always a spacesuit, right?
Rocky
42m 26s
Mm-hmm.
Jords
42m 27s
Like people with credentials
42m 29s
locked doors.
Rocky
42m 31s
Mm-hmm.
Jords
42m 31s
Like compartmentalization is a really big deal and you don't always have access to things.
Rocky
42m 35s
Escape pods, I think, are another big one.
Jords
42m 37s
Yep, absolutely.
Rocky
42m 38s
Gives you a great end goal.
42m 40s
Self-destruct systems, another good one.
Jords
42m 41s
Yep, self-destruct system.
42m 43s
There's like the engines and their fuel source is a classic one.
42m 48s
Like lots of like pairings of these things that you can be like,
42m 51s
there's a problem with this and the players will go,
42m 53s
that means we need to go over here.
Rocky
42m 54s
I think life support is the other big one.
Jords
42m 56s
Yeah, super.
42m 57s
Oxygen and life support.
42m 59s
They're constants in this genre.
43m 2s
You can always see them in there.
43m 4s
I absolutely love just like popping all of these down.
43m 8s
Sometimes I'll hard code them onto the map.
43m 10s
Other times I'll just have them in my back pocket as the thing that I like I could bring up as a part of a complication.
43m 15s
And that prep is done once and you've got it for literally every game that you run in this genre.
Rocky
43m 22s
and I think you have you've like you've hit on something really interesting here which is that you can start to layer these things together so we've got this like substrate of our ship that is filled with or our base that is filled with a small amount of space with some solutions in it we have our antagonist um which is like shaping time creating time pressure the same way our environment is creating space pressure and then in between them you have this layer of like oh and And then there's also the environment.
43m 52s
You know, environmental hazards that will kill you and the, but also these like environmental affordances, you can almost like start to have one go into the other.
44m 1s
So again, I think that life did very blatantly was like, they trapped the alien outside the ship.
44m 9s
And then one of the ways it could get back in was through the propulsion system.
44m 13s
So the alien tries to climb back in through the rocket jets.
44m 16s
They're like, great.
44m 16s
That means we just fire the rockets and that will help us kill it.
44m 20s
but they do this so often as it runs around the ship that firstly they run out of fuel and secondly they accidentally de-orbit the ISS and they've got to like boost it back up again so it's like you've got this thing where like our active antagonist has interacted with this environmental affordance and made like a whole new class of problems and that's exactly it right it's like you've got this active antagonist and it is exactly that thing that you were talking about where it's like it's engines and their fuel and we use the engines to try and get rid of the antagonists,
Jords
44m 28s

[laughs]

Rocky
44m 54s
but now the engines are out of fuel and also the space station is out of orbit and it's this like quite a complex problem, yeah.
Jords
44m 58s
Mhmm, new problem to resolve.
45m 1s
Yep, we get to constantly fight against the environment while also dealing with the time pressure of the entity.
Rocky
45m 7s
exactly and so it's almost like a little sandwich right it's like you've got you've got the the entity on one layer running around yeah as I said causing time pressure you've got the environment underneath giving you a constrained set of affordances and spaces to work with and in between you have all of these environmental hazards which interact with both in interest
Jords
45m 25s
I reckon that's probably all I need on on the environment front now I feel like I've got a pretty good handle I've got my map I've got like my things dotted around there I've got like my pairwise problems of doors and credentials and like spacesuits and airlocks and yada yada
Rocky
45m 45s
Also, we have a "if left to its own devices, the creature will do X".
Jords
45m 49s
yeah I think the the next big thing then is fleshing out the motivations of my creature
Rocky
45m 50s
We have our timeline.
Jords
45m 55s
and what it's going to do over time how it's going to make the situation irrevocably worse that results in death for everyone unless they do something to stop it and then I'm just going to do that marrying together of the thing so like straight away right at the start you said something about like you wouldn't keep the like flamethrower over here and I was like yeah well of course like a flamethrower is a very destructive weapon it could be super bad like a lot of people are like oh, the fire is bad, but I'm instantly like, it will suck.
46m 25s
It will suffocate everyone on the spaceship because it burns all the oxygen.
Rocky
46m 27s
Mm-hm-hm-hm-hm-hm-hm-hm.
Jords
46m 29s
So, of course, somebody has the access code to be able to open up the locker where the flamethrowers are.
46m 36s
And that somebody could be one of the first casualties to the monster.
46m 40s
So, their corpse is somewhere over there, and you have to go to the corpse if you want to get the flamethrower.
46m 46s
Like, there's really easy ways to link these things up that cause adventure to happen.
46m 51s
And you don't have to hard-code it, necessarily.
46m 53s
you don't have to say
46m 55s
you need the flamethrower to resolve this problem the players can just do that on their own accord you just have to like drop these these fun bits around the environment for them to make interesting choices
Rocky
47m 7s
So I think that's our prep. I want to talk a little bit about how we facilitate this because I have some questions. I think the first one for me is, how do you do tension?
Jords
47m 12s
Yep.
47m 14s
All right.
47m 20s
You pull really tightly on both ends.
Rocky
47m 25s
How do we run tension at the table in a way that feels tense and is not boring and also not,
47m 36s
I guess deceitful Sending into comedy is the other risk Is that like as soon as you make things tense I think players are going to want to defuse that with a joke And I don't think that's necessarily what we want Outside of our kind of scheduled down time
Jords
47m 51s
I really feel it.
47m 52s
I've kind of come to accept that it's impossible to stamp out the quick humor, especially when often you end up in these absurd situations that it's just so right for someone to make a wisecrack about.
48m 6s
So I do act a little bit like the tone police.
48m 10s
I will never join in on the joke.
48m 13s
I will always re-emphasize the difficult situation there.
Rocky
48m 18s
Mm-hmm. So it's like a gentle redirect back to, it's like, you let them have their joke maybe for a moment and then you redirect back into the...
Jords
48m 25s
I might crack a smile, but I'll never build on it.
48m 27s
And that's hard for me, right?
Rocky
48m 28s
Yeah.
Jords
48m 29s
That's genuinely hard for me.
Rocky
48m 32s
I am always going to want to get in on the gag and I think that's a real challenge is to be like, nope, you as the game master you are.
48m 39s
This is one of those genres where it's like, it's going to live or die on whether or not you can set the tone.
48m 46s
I think that's a really hard one.
Jords
48m 48s
I also think because of that I try to aim for these sessions to not go longer than three hours I think three hours is is a lot i'd be happy to crawl a dungeon for like four hours or longer like i've done a full work day in a dungeon before no big deal but maintaining tension and like having appropriate releases is much more taxing so I would aim for a three-ish yep fatigue is the right word
Rocky
49m 8s
the fatigue is real genuinely I would not stop like I know a lot of the time the way that we tend to structure these sessions is you do a couple of hours you have your pizza break you do a couple of hours more I'd be like nope we are eating at the end it's like this is we are getting on the ride and we are because it's so it is so hard to get that anxiety back once everyone has had a pizza and
Jords
49m 26s
yep we've either eaten first or last yeah
Rocky
49m 38s
I think it has to run contiguously like we want to be white knuckling this we've got to run this all the way through in one shot because so much of it is like you know that it's that for pizza
Jords
49m 48s
Yeah, you know all those famous roller coasters that have a big gap in the middle for people to sit down on?
49m 56s
So, yeah, full end-to-end experience, three-ish hours, pretty tight and fully modulated throughout.
Rocky
50m 3s
Yep.
50m 4s
Yep.
50m 5s
Yep.
Jords
50m 8s
So, just to start with, right?
50m 10s
We have our scene setting where we go through and say, like, what's everyone's role in this situation?
50m 18s
Work function, like, I reckon that probably takes up a solid, like, 20-ish minutes at the start.
Rocky
50m 20s
Hmm.
Jords
50m 25s
We just establish normalcy.
50m 28s
I quite like using the theme of, like, what's the mundane task at work that you're doing and how does another player affect it?
50m 38s
And I just kind of, like, run through all of the different characters in the zone and introduce NPCs along the way as, like, incidentals in this case.
50m 46s
It's almost like the opening of an office space, where he sits down to work and every one of the managers comes by and says like, oh, did you get the memo about the TPS reports? Like, it's just really mundane. And then we start the escalation, right? There's got to be a triggering event that happens. And I think you're allowed to, if you want to, to drop some foreshadowing clues before the triggering event that just like kind of seem a little bit out of place and can be recontextualized later once they know a thing is afoot.
51m 17s
but there is a significant trigger that occurs right and that's our point of no return that's where where the ratchet starts going up and it doesn't come down we went for exactly opposite metaphors there so this is where it's no longer a standard work day and we're analyzing the artifact or we've received the distress signal or the like other
Rocky
51m 25s
You've dropped off the rollercoaster, yep.
51m 50s
so yeah we spark that curiosity we pull them into the problem things escalate we hit some kind of
51m 57s
mini climax then we have our first regroup and plan I think our session kind of then follows that pattern maybe a couple more times of like make a plan head out into the danger things escalate come to a head probably go wrong fall back and plan again I think the amount of time we get the
52m 20s
fall back and plan gets less each time
Jords
52m 23s
there's another resource that dwindles as well and that's like npc cast and crew
Rocky
52m 29s
Okay, so we're going to come back to that.
52m 33s
But yeah, I think that's kind of our core gameplay loop is like a really intense run.
52m 38s
We fall back and regroup.
52m 41s
My rule of three brain says three times.
52m 43s
I think we could go up to four, but I don't actually think we get that many run throughs of it.
Jords
52m 48s
Cycles.
Rocky
52m 50s
This is not a drawn out thing.
52m 53s
And then yeah, each time we regroup, we get a little bit less time.
52m 56s
And as a game master, that's where we're kind of using those kicks to like force those breaks to get shorter and shorter and shorter.
53m 4s
It's like you start to hear scuttling in the walls.
53m 6s
You start to like, something's moving on the motion tracker.
53m 9s
And I think that's also what we use to keep things moving to pick things back up.
53m 12s
If a player does something like makes a joke,
53m 14s
those are also our tools to bring things back.
53m 18s
Cause we can't just say, come back to the,
53m 21s
you know, where we were before.
53m 22s
I think we then need to, you know,
53m 25s
you're in the, in the big room, there's chains,
53m 27s
everything's dripping.
53m 29s
Someone makes a joke right you can't just remind them that everything is dripping you have to be like you hear something rustle in the distance and so I think to jump back to our prep when we're designing these spaces that's the thing we want to make sure we have a huge pile of on a table in cards even just as a list of like here are things in this space that might make a sound that might move that might smell funny like.
53m 58s
here are the things
Jords
53m 59s
think I wouldn't even prep this as cards I just have like a scratch pad with these things like what are things that they might hear and then I just have like and I just pick the one that fits
Rocky
54m 7s
Yeah.
54m 11s
Exactly.
54m 12s
And like from, I think what I'm trying to get at is like from a facilitation point of view, like having, putting some things in, it doesn't even have to be a list, right?
54m 19s
It's just, it could just be that you have a really clear visual about what that environment is like, which gives you things that you can pull from.
54m 26s
It's like, we know that the floor is grating.
54m 28s
Okay.
54m 29s
You notice that one of the grates is not where it was, right?
54m 32s
like all of that detail that you put into the environment that's all tools for you to ratchet the tension up and and to put the tension back in like I think that's where those two things intersect is like that's your tool for getting tension back but you need to make sure you
Jords
54m 52s
- Absolutely, like a little bit of prep goes a long way for being able to think of the like,
54m 58s
what atmospheric effect can I deploy here?
55m 1s
It's like coming up with names.
55m 2s
It's actually pretty tricky to do on the fly.
Rocky
55m 4s
exactly so easy and then yeah I think that's our our structure is we we just ramp the tension ramp the like fear of the unknown until something goes wrong or until we achieve our goal but probably it's probably a combination of both and we go back and regroup which brings me to my other question because the thing that goes wrong in all of these movies is that someone gets picked off.
Jords
55m 5s
If you do it ahead of time, it's easiest part.
Rocky
55m 31s
So how are we handling the fact that we want our crew to dwindle down without excluding players by having their characters be killed?
55m 41s
Because I actually don't know that I want it to be a given that everyone makes it to the end just because they're a PC.
Jords
55m 46s
Oh absolutely not. No. So I love in this type of adventure to stock extra cast and crew because if the players die, sorry player characters die, they can inhabit one of those shells.
56m 3s
So like we've already established isolation is a big deal which means narratively it's a little bit hard to pull in a replacement character. Like one of those eternal or you universal elements for this world is like cryopods. So maybe I have like there is a cryopod room somewhere and that's where new characters could come out of because I definitely want Threat of Death to be very present throughout this. No one is safe and I might be able to kill off a NPC really easily but I still want to be able to like point the trigger at the players at every early opportunity.
56m 44s
like nothing in influences behavior like somebody just getting vacuumed out
Rocky
56m 50s
Yeah, I think I had in my head that everyone is maybe sharing control over a dwindling group and making decisions about what they all do in it, but that almost becomes more of a story game, and I think that does, you do start to lose some of the attachment to the character that means a lot when they die.
Jords
57m 7s
It's okay for me to have like an extra character or two tag along with the party, but I like reasons to separate them out as well.
57m 14s
So it's like group A can do something and the spotlight's going to be on group A, but group B might have to go off and do something else.
57m 21s
In some adventures I've had it be just like because of the compartmentalization, they're just locked behind a different area.
57m 29s
And that area will open up if a character, a player character dies and I need an excuse to introduce them.
57m 35s
or maybe my player's have to go unlock that area to get access to them.
57m 40s
But I don't enjoy running heaps of NPCs at once.
57m 45s
So I'll usually make it pretty clear,
57m 47s
like, they're not the protagonists of this story.
57m 49s
You guys are.
Rocky
57m 50s
Mm. Yeah.
Jords
57m 51s
They're just flavor off screen.
57m 53s
But if somebody dies,
57m 55s
maybe one of them gets raised up to suddenly be on the pedestal
Rocky
58m
Yeah I think that's a good way to do it and I think you can have some fun with it as well as like with the cryopod example you hand them a new character sheet and it's like you wake up and like the lights that the power is out and the alert siren is running and like you have no idea what's going on and having that like that can then become I think a bonus like little run through like solo situation.
Jords
58m 27s
it re-emphasizes how bad the status quo is because like i've had this happen before and I love the way the the players that i've had play into the like I went to sleep and everything was fine and i've woken up and it's bad and the player knows that information but the character is learning it for the first time and I love watching that play out at the table
Rocky
58m 40s
It's so bad, guys.
58m 49s
Yeah I think that's a good way to handle it. I'm also like if it gets to the third act and we're like in the last 20 minutes of the session it's like you know what you've died and you just get to like be a part of the vibe for the last little bit.
Jords
59m 4s
there's a certain cutoff point you can die before this point and just be like inhabit a new shell but after this point we're we're riding it to the bitter end
Rocky
59m 12s
right it's like after the last I think regroup right like we we've talked about how we have these like these little surges it's like after the last regroup it's the final run to the escape pods it's like if you die between the the crew hab with the map room really is what it is if you die between the map room and the escape pod in the last 20 minutes of the session it's like that's it you get to narrate a cool death for yourself and like but we're just like running this through now i think. But I think that's only acceptable in that last...
Jords
59m 43s
Yep, I agree with that.
59m 44s
I mostly want my players to be doing things all the time and they shouldn't be punished for death.
59m 49s
And I want that death in the last act to be like super meaningful as it's like, oh no, things went bad.
Rocky
59m 54s
Hmm.
Jords
59m 57s
Oh, the humanity.
59m 59s
And then they just get to be the cheerleader on the side.
1h 2s
Like I've never had anyone complain about that.
1h 4s
And I've done quite a few adventures like this.
Rocky
1h 6s
Yeah. Yeah, I think those are my big questions is like,
Jords
1h 7s
Now.
Rocky
1h 8s
how do we modulate tone and how do we handle character death?
Jords
1h 13s
One last thing that I think is worth mentioning just for the prep side.
1h 17s
And that's as we build our entity,
1h 19s
I do want it to have some way that I've thought of that the players could resolve the effects.
1h 27s
I could return it back to a dormant state or like push it away or escape.
1h 31s
I want to have at least one solution in my back pocket just so I know it's a solvable situation and I haven't just like it's just impending doom with no respite.
1h 41s
I think it's important that there is always a sliver of hope that they might be able to survive the thing. And if they come up with their own solution that I didn't think of, sick, love it, that's great, that's why I play these games.
1h 53s
But I do want to have at least one way in my back pocket that they can
Rocky
1h 58s
I think that's really interesting. My last thing was like, I want to make sure that each of these characters, especially if we're going to have the opportunity of maybe people picking up a character a little bit further in, I want to make sure each of these characters has a reason to live.
1h 1m 14s
Maybe they have a kid at home, maybe this is their last run before retirement. I want them to have a reason to want to try and survive and not just throw themselves into a meat grinder.
1h 1m 25s
and I want it to feel if they are the one or two or whoever who make it to the end.
1h 1m 31s
I want it to feel deserved that they survived.
1h 1m 35s
You know, I want there to be a moment where it's like,
1h 1m 37s
the guy who survived is the guy who gets to go home and meet his family, right?
1h 1m 41s
Like it's that kind of stuff.
1h 1m 43s
So yeah, as well as there being a like,
1h 1m 45s
yep, there has to be a sliver of hope for like how we might defeat the antagonist.
1h 1m 50s
I think for our protagonist,
1h 1m 51s
there has to be as part of that day-to-day boring stuff,
1h 1m 55s
we want to introduce a reason for them to want to get out
Jords
1h 1m 58s
Yep. I think that's totally fair. And I think that also alleviates, like, this is an edge case.
1h 2m 3s
I've only ever seen this in one player before, but it's where they start to inhabit a more meta perspective where they're like, throw themselves into the meat grinder. If I'm not inhabiting any particular character, they mean nothing to me. So they're an expendable resource. So it'll be like,
1h 2m 20s
oh yeah, I'll throw that person at the airlock to see if they can bust it open. Oh no, they got sucked out into space all right jump onto the next person and it's like that breaks the fiction for me and I think it's it's so rare like it's literally only happened once and it was in my early days of gming but if you have characters that are like no there's a purpose to this character they they care to survive I think that goes a little step towards establishing the right psychology for this
Rocky
1h 2m 29s
Hmm. Yeah.
1h 2m 48s
Absolutely, all right so what are you going to run this in? I have some thoughts.
Jords
1h 2m 55s
I have some thoughts, too.
1h 2m 56s
I've got two.
1h 2m 58s
I'm going to go with the one that I would absolutely do it in, and I have done it in, and I really enjoy.
1h 3m 4s
I would run this in Mothership.
Rocky
1h 3m 7s
I have heard so much about Mothership. We went to PAX recently and I feel like every second conversation we had with someone about RPGs, they were like, oh, have you tried Mothership? And I was like, I have not, but you are not the first person to say this to me. It's so hot right now. It feels like, yeah.
Jords
1h 3m 7s
I adore Mothership.
1h 3m 17s
mm-hmm so hard right now like in part I think because it has an incredible community with just like boatloads of material to be able to like dive into um but it's also just a phenomenal game it it's character generation sheet is a work of art the user experience of it is phenomenal you're able to whip up a character so easily they're like you can murder them mid-session and it doesn't cause the game to grind to a halt like it's it's so effective in that regard i've run a bunch of sessions of mothership I really enjoy how the rules just kind of get out of the way but they do emphasize like there is ludonarrative resonance it's really hard to be a superhero in a mothership game and sometimes like you might get access to the big gun but that doesn't make you a superhero so just think of reinforces a lot of the premises it's really easy to access it takes so little effort for me to run that game and I don't know if i've mentioned this before on the pod but it's warden survival guide warden is the name of the game master in this the system is maybe one of the single greatest game mastering supplements that i've ever read so clean that's such a beige opinion everyone agrees on this, but it's just very well done.
1h 4m 47s
The Mothership would probably be my first point
Rocky
1h 4m 49s
I think my look I would probably consider running in Mothership as well just based on how much I've heard about it and it is so obviously built for this um my go-to for horror is Dread which if you haven't heard of it before is the one where there's no dice you just have a Jenga tower in the middle of the table and every time you want to take an action you have to pull something out of the Jenga tower and I think just in terms of like creating anxiety at the table
Jords
1h 5m 18s
Yeah, you have a visual representation of anxiety at all times.
Rocky
1h 5m 19s
and the like the horror of the tower falling over and it's like within the rules it's like if the tower falls over it's like that whatever you've just done is killed your character which in some settings doesn't make sense but I think in this one where we have this like very active antagonist it's like okay you were trying to you might have been pulling to like a try and you know hack the airlock door but like you set off the alarm and like that attracts the creature and you die right
1h 5m 49s
it's because you have this active antagonist it gives you such a neat way to make that tower collapse part of the fiction in a way that makes sense and to make every action something that could possibly kill you which I think is how it should feel like it also just gives you that structure right because it's like the tower collapses someone dies that run is over and we retreat regroup go back
1h 6m 19s
to the map room look at the map make a new plan while we set the tower back up and then it's back out into the fray again like it does require you to think on your feet quite a bit as a as a game master because you don't know when that tower is going to fall over and it's like okay well literally someone could die at any time but on the flip side but on the flip side in terms of like creating that ludonarrative resonance and creating that like it does the structure it does the structure of like things get tenser and tenser and tenser and then someone dies and we reset like it does that thing on its own and I just I love that I love a core mechanic that doesn't just feel right in the moment but also like when you look at how it operates in the the the long run of the game it's like oh this unlike a dice roll like this has a shape to it and the shape is a build up and drop and a build up and drop and a build up and drop literally so yeah I am a big fan of it it's quite old school I think it was like it's like an early 2000s thing there's probably other games that do similar stuff out there but I really dig it
Jords
1h 6m 36s
and I think you want to like force the players to take lots of actions so that the tower becomes unwieldy yeah especially if you want it to collapse more than once in a session
1h 7m 35s
Look, I can't see any fault with that.
1h 7m 37s
I think Dread is a really, really tight tie into it.
1h 7m 40s
And the last few pulls on a Dread Tower, it's like, it could be any of us.
Rocky
1h 7m 46s
Hmm.
Jords
1h 7m 46s
We have nothing.
1h 7m 48s
It could be me.
1h 7m 50s
And like, you want somebody else to do the pull, you know?
Rocky
1h 7m 50s
Nobody is safe.
Jords
1h 7m 54s
Yeah, I love that.
1h 7m 55s
It really reinforces the behaviors you want.
1h 7m 59s
My other suggestion is a little game called Stoneburners.
1h 8m 5s
Have I, have I told you about this one before?
Rocky
1h 8m 8s
Yes you have and you've actually stolen my second suggestion.
Jords
1h 8m 8s
Like, so Stoneburners is a game built on the Breathless system.
1h 8m 17s
The premise of it is you're all space dwarves and you've inherited your like long lost relative's spooky haunted mine.
1h 8m 25s
And you're trying to reestablish the base there.
1h 8m 29s
And you go out to different asteroids.
1h 8m 31s
Every adventure is like a dig through another asteroid.
1h 8m 35s
To retrieve some goodies and bring them back.
1h 8m 37s
But the only problem is that all of the asteroids are infested with demons.
1h 8m 42s
So it's very like Deep Rock Galactic with spooky horror elements.
1h 8m 47s
And I've played a bunch of sessions of this one with various groups.
1h 8m 50s
And it does have the same sort of cadence.
1h 8m 53s
Where the Breathless system you have a single dice as your stat.
1h 8m 58s
Every time you use it you downgrade that dice.
1h 9m 1s
And like the threshold for success is static.
1h 9m 5s
Dice gets smaller.
1h 9m 5s
The chances that you're going to just outright accomplish something rapidly diminish.
1h 9m 10s
And then eventually you reach a point where the best possible outcome you could have.
1h 9m 14s
Is success with consequences.
1h 9m 17s
And at any point you can take a beat.
1h 9m 20s
And get all of your dice back to their nominal values.
1h 9m 24s
But that introduces a change in the fiction.
1h 9m 26s
And I think that kind of perfectly replicates how you want to escape.
1h 9m 31s
You want to like replenish your resources.
1h 9m 35s
I'm in the map room.
1h 9m 36s
And the bad thing gets kicked along.
Rocky
1h 9m 39s
Mm.
Jords
1h 9m 39s
The bad thing just like I get to advance my escalation of that.
1h 9m 43s
I have the kicks already planned.
1h 9m 44s
So whenever the players want to get back to their proper fight and strength.
1h 9m 48s
I just get to advance whatever the nefarious thing is doing.
1h 9m 51s
So really closely maps that structure already.
Rocky
1h 9m 52s
Yeah, no, that was, that was absolutely going to be mine as well.
1h 9m 58s
I think the, the, love it.
Jords
1h 9m 59s
Scooped!
1h 10m 3s
Would you run this?
1h 10m 5s
In 5e.
1h 10m 5s
In 5e.
1h 10m 9s
Yeah.
1h 10m 9s
I wouldn't either.
1h 10m 10s
And it's for the same reason why I actually don't think Curse of Strahd is a very good horror game.
1h 10m 16s
Because we're playing with superheroes.
1h 10m 18s
And they have just so many ways of solving problems that it's actually really hard to threaten them properly.
Rocky
1h 10m 25s
I think for me,
1h 10m 26s
it's just that this is so inextricably tied to the environment,
1h 10m 31s
right?
Jords
1h 10m 33s
Yeah, but I wouldn't even use like a space themed 5e game for this.
Rocky
1h 10m 40s
Yeah that look that's fair. But again that's the thing for me is like space-themed 5e always ends up feeling kind of it doesn't feel right it doesn't it just doesn't work.
Jords
1h 10m 51s
it doesn't emulate the genre very well it it is trying to use an engine that that does its thing in a different place like you're square pegging this round hole
Rocky
1h 11m 1s
Yeah, again, like so many reasons, but like among them, very difficult to spin up a new character quickly and to learn how to pilot a new character quickly, right?
1h 11m 13s
Like it starts to get really hard to have that attrition that we want to be able to have.
Jords
1h 11m 19s
also player expectations around the the longevity of a character mismatch with it which makes it really hard to truly threaten them with death so yeah just like from an outside perspective lots of things that don't work from an inside perspective lots of structural elements that don't work I have I will again I i will sin again for sure I have a lot of joy in these um i've never just straight run event horizon because most people that I play with have seen it but it is a dream to one day just run exactly that situation yeah the pre-req is have you seen event horizon don't ask me why I don't watch that it's such a good movie yeah would you
Rocky
1h 11m 35s
Would you run this?
1h 11m 39s
Yeah.
1h 11m 55s
find some people who have not seen it and yeah don't ask me any more questions I would not steal a movie don't ask me any more questions um yeah I think I would I think I would I think probably again I I miss when I was a younger man and I got to run a Halloween game every year because I think this would be perfect for we did just be like
1h 12m 25s
for Halloween instead of doing a party we'll just run a dread game and we did a couple of years of like just running a fun weird dread scenario one year it was like stranger things but with witches like just like just like random stuff and I miss I miss my annual Halloween dread game but that is the context in which I would run it and the system I would probably go to as well.
Jords
1h 12m 47s
Toad's Fair.
1h 12m 49s
Yeah, this episode will come out probably just after spooky Halloween time.
1h 12m 56s
But in time for Mothership Month of 2026, which is November.
Rocky
1h 12m 56s
But, conveniently...
Jords
1h 13m 4s
So I think like Halloween is the kicking off point, the opening of the door to a whole month worth of spooky Mothership product.
Rocky
1h 13m 12s
And look, this is not 100% deliberate, but we did want to do something spooky and we were like, hey, space horror, we know that Mothership Month is a thing and Halloween is a thing and like.
1h 13m 27s
So yeah, happy Mothership Month to those who celebrate.
Jords
1h 13m 30s
for those who observe um as a final sign-off point I just I do want to plug one adventure in particular that I really enjoy from mothership uh it's called dead weight you can find it on itch I don't want to provide any spoilers for anyone but if you're into collecting mothership modules that you may or may not run throw five bucks its way it's very good
Rocky
1h 13m 31s
Enjoy this accidental collision of communities.
1h 14m 1s
I will not be checking it out because I just live in hope that one day I will get you to run Mothership for me.
Jords
1h 14m 6s
I also live in that home.
Rocky
1h 14m 9s
All right, this has been Playtonics.
1h 14m 12s
I have been Rocky.
Jords
1h 14m 14s
I continue to be Jords.
Rocky
1h 14m 15s
CJ.
1h 14m 17s
You can find us on the internet at playtonics.net.
1h 14m 19s
You can find the show wherever you get your podcasts,
1h 14m 21s
but you already knew that.
1h 14m 22s
If you enjoy the show, please send it to a friend.
1h 14m 26s
Send it to your game master.
1h 14m 27s
Be like, hey, let's try something different.
1h 14m 29s
If you are a game master, send a it to another game master.
1h 14m 32s
We love to get the word of mouth out there and spread the show around and see people popping into the community. Speaking of which, the place we would love to see if you are already a listener and you're not already in there is the Discord.
1h 14m 47s
There's a join link in the podcast show notes and also on the website.
1h 14m 53s
And that's, there's not a huge number of us in there, but it is always a really great conversation
1h 15m 1s
after each episode. I feel like a lot of the time, like, half of my good ideas about the episode only happen in the comments of the episode thread.
Jords
1h 15m 8s
yeah once it hits the other folks and we're like oh our ideas are popping off now let's dig deeper if you would like extra reading join us in the discord
Rocky
1h 15m 10s
And I'm like, ah, I wish we could have had this conversation about the episode before the episode.
1h 15m 15s
So if you're not...
1h 15m 19s
You can also find us in other places on the internet. We're on text-based socials.
1h 15m 29s
So that's Mastodon Threads and...
1h 15m 31s
And BlueSky, we are on Reddit.
1h 15m 34s
So if you see you slash Playtonics posting in r slash RPG,
1h 15m 37s
fang us an upvote.
1h 15m 39s
And if you see anyone asking in RPG,
1h 15m 41s
like, oh, how do I run this thing?
1h 15m 43s
Please feel free to tell them about the show.
1h 15m 46s
We are fairly limited in how much we can self-promote on Reddit.
1h 15m 50s
But if you guys tell people about the show,
1h 15m 52s
that's actually really good for us because you're allowed to do it and we're not.
1h 15m 56s
So if you see those threads pop up about like,
1h 15m 59s
how do I run a game like alien please feel free to plug the show because you're you are allowed to do that in a way that we can't so words and mouths put some mouths on put some words in your mouth no yes I don't this got away from me thanks so much for listening we will catch you next month bye
Jords
1h 16m 9s
like our show mostly spreads by word of mouth so please words of mouth so
1h 16m 19s
Figure it out.
1h 16m 28s
Bye.
1h 16m 33s
Oh, was that the airlock cycling?
Rocky
1h 16m 37s
Ah!
Jords
1h 16m 45s
Boom, nailed it.
Made with Transcriptionist